Electrical Shock Investigation Discovery Questions Expert Article

Through a forensic investigation, it can often be determined whether electrical shock conditions were present, whether an electric shock occurred, and if electric shock did occur, the cause or causes. Variables such as the type of product or equipment, environment, service history, and who was injured may all influence causation and standard of care.

This article outlines the questions that should be asked, and discovery items to request, in an investigation of an electrical shock injury.

Electrical Shock Expert Discovery Questions

Electrical Shock Investigation Discovery Questions

Conditions for electric shock can arise anywhere electricity is used. Electrical circuits, appliances, light fixtures, and safety devices etc. require proper manufacturing, installation, service, and testing to prevent shock injuries. These roles are not always performed by individuals and companies with proper qualifications and competency.

At the outset of a new case, there are certain pieces of information that can be helpful for your expert’s investigation. Having this information available when sourcing an expert can enable experts to provide initial feedback on the technical merits of various case strategies.

Fundamentals of Electricity

The foundational terms and concepts of electrical engineering can be confusing to industry outsiders. For a primer on voltage, resistance, current, and how each variable affects the injury potential in electrical shock cases, consider reading our article on the Fundamentals of Electricity.

Discovery Questions for Electrical Shock Cases

Investigations can be aided by information from the examination of evidence, service records, model numbers, prior complaints, electrical testing, and descriptions of past performance and history. Preserving evidence for examination and obtaining service records for post-incident corrections is ideal, though it is not always possible. If there is evidence available, regardless of whether changes or corrections have been made, your expert will want access to it.

What were the qualifications of the person who was shocked?

Many electrical shocks occur during the installation or servicing of equipment. It may be relevant to determine the training and qualifications of the injured party for the electrical work being performed. Did the injured person follow best practices? Should they have known best practices? Did they know enough to understand the risks associated with their actions?

Are product labels in place and in good condition?

Many electrical products will feature warning labels to notify of potential shock hazards. Your expert will likely want to know if warning labels were covered, removed, or damaged in a manner that limited their effectiveness, and if they aligned with applicable standards and regulations. Additionally, were they in a language the user could understand?

Was the equipment verified to be de-energized prior to work? Did the work require the equipment to be energized during servicing?

Maintenance and service work of electrical systems is to be performed after establishing an electrically safe work condition. Steps taken to establish an electrically safe work condition include application of Lockout/Tagout (LOTO) and confirmation of the removal of electrical power with a voltage meter while wearing appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE).

Conversely, there are specific instances where energized work is required. There are strict conditions for when this is appropriate. Were the correct processes followed and analyses performed leading up to the energized work? Was appropriate PPE worn?

Were energized components guarded?

When the worker is not in the electrical trade the above requirements are still relevant as they apply to all workers who are exposed to electrical hazards. Maintenance work by non-electrical trades may involve accessing spaces where electrical hazards exist.

Were tools required to remove protective covers? If maintenance is performed on energized equipment, have insulated connectors been used to protect against accidental contact?

In some types of equipment, it may have been appropriate to install an interlock to de-energize systems before contact can be made.

Was the right equipment installed in the right way?

This is particularly relevant for incidental contacts and electrical shocks not related to work duties. Electrical equipment is generally considered safe if it is used in accordance with its listing and is installed in accordance with the National Electrical Code (NEC).

Correct usage and installation of electrical equipment allow us to safely utilize electrical power in our daily lives, but when these requirements are not met there is an increased risk of electrical shock. Construction documentation such as specifications, contracts, submittals, and drawings may provide details concerning the electrical equipment and where and how it was to be installed.

In product related cases, electrical design schematics can provide useful information.  

Have other parties serviced the equipment?

Service records are a great place to start, as they often contain significant information. Absent documentation, an expert may still be able to determine a device’s relative service history through a visual inspection. Is paint scuffed from tool marks or around access panels? Is there any evidence of repair, indicated by field soldering, wiring alterations, or an inconsistent use of electrical tape or wire nuts?

Has the building wiring been modified since the fixture or appliance was installed?

Amateur electrical work can cause a host of problems, including overloading a circuit, negating protective devices, or causing fault conditions which means to have current flow in an unintended path. Performing a visual inspection of conduit, wiring, and other system components for consistency may reveal alterations which could affect liability.

Are injuries commensurate to the exposure?

Electrical injuries can range from pain, muscular contractions, and difficulty in breathing, to burns, cardiac arrest, respiratory failure, and death. The severity of injury is primarily based on the amount of current, the duration of current and the path of current through the body. For a more in-depth view of this topic, see our article on Electric Shock Injuries.

Investigating Electrical Shock Cases

The prevention of electrical shocks is accomplished by keeping the flow of electricity in intended paths, safety devices acting quickly to de-energize when electrical currents flow in unintended paths, and by grounding methods for preventing differences in voltage levels on exposed surfaces.

Electrical shocks are also prevented by enclosing or guarding against contact with energized surfaces and the prevention of the intrusion of materials, such as water, into electrical equipment. Additionally, the work being performed at the time can be analyzed for compliance with well-established safety procedures. Failing to meet these requirements can increase the risk of not only electrical shock injury but of severe injury from arc flash events.

The electrical engineers at Robson Forensic regularly investigate electrical shock injuries to determine their cause. These investigations typically include an evaluation of equipment installations in accordance with the National Electrical Code (NEC), the National Electrical Safety Code (NESC), appliances, products, and equipment designs, maintenance and repair issues, presence of defects, and the adequacy of warnings and instructions.

For more information submit an inquiry or call us at 800.813.6736.

Featured Expert

Jeffrey M. Kobilka, Electrical Engineer & Industrial Controls Expert

Jeffrey M. Kobilka, P.E., C.F.E.I.

Electrical Engineer & Industrial Controls Expert
Jeff Kobilka is an electrical engineer with more than a decade of professional experience in plants and manufacturing environments that produce advanced, technical products. In these roles, Jeff was… read more.

Related

View All Articles

Electrical Shock Injuries & the Fundamentals of Electricity

By James M. Orosz
Expert Article

In this article, electrical engineer, Jim Orosz, P.E., provides an introduction to the basics of electricity. He discusses voltage, resistance, current, and how each variable affects the injury…

Electrical Shock Injuries: Typical Causes of Electrical Exposure

By Les Winter
Expert Article

In this article electrical engineer, Les Winter, P.E., provides an introduction to the most common causes of electrical shock injuries that occur in domestic, commercial, industrial, and construction…

Electrocutions & Shock Injuries: the Basics of Human Electrical Exposures

By Kenneth J. Kutchek
Expert Article

In this article, electrical engineer, Kenneth Kutchek, P.E. provides an introduction to electrocutions and electric shock injuries. His discussion includes the basic principles of electricity,…