Fatal Tractor-Trailer Accident Results in $3.5M Verdict Expert Article

Fatal Tractor Trailer Investigation

Commercial trucking expert, Brooks Rugemer, was retained on behalf of the plaintiff in a case where a federal jury awarded nearly $3.5 million related to a fatal tractor-trailer accident. The victim in this case, a mechanic, was killed instantly when the tractor-trailer he was repairing lurched forward because the driver allegedly pressed the ignition button while it was still in gear.

PDF of Verdict Summary is available for download.

Facts & Allegations

On Aug. 18, 2008, plaintiff’s decedent Jared Conlon, 26, a mobile mechanic, died while repairing a tractor-trailer that had been pulled over by state police, in Breezewood. The truck had failed a safety inspection by a state police officer, who cited fault with the vehicle’s braking system.

The tractor-trailer was driven by Cornelius Carlos Hart and William Bradley McDaniels, who were driving in the course and scope of their employment with Trans National Trucking LLC. Conlon’s widow alleged that, while her husband was performing brake repairs on the truck, Conlon raised the right rear corner of the vehicle up on a bottle jack and asked Hart to bleed out air from the brake lines by tapping on the brakes.

Two hours later, after working on the vehicle, Conlon asked Hart to start the truck in order to get pressure back into the brake line. Conlon’s widow claimed that when Hart started the truck, he failed to ensure it was in neutral, thereby causing it to lurch forward five to six feet upon starting. This caused the tractor-trailer to fall from its bottle jack onto Conlon, who was under the rear wheels at the time and died instantly.

Conlon’s widow sued Hart, Trans National Trucking and McDaniels (who was voluntarily dismissed prior to jury selection), for wrongful death.

According to the plaintiffs’ trucking industry expert, commercial truck drivers are always trained to take a truck out of gear before starting it, and the accident was therefore entirely the result of Hart’s negligence. The defendants denied the allegations and maintained that the plaintiff was comparatively negligent. The defense argued that Conlon remained in charge of the service and repair work, and he told Hart to get into the cab and start the engine during his post-repair inspection of the tractor.

Knowing that he had instructed Hart to get into the cab and start the tractor, and at obvious and serious risk to himself, Conlon then immediately placed his own body underneath the frame of the tractor, at which time the tractor came off the bottle jack; as a result, Conlon was fatally struck by the frame of the tractor. Counsel asserted that Conlon did not chock the wheels, use jack stands, or otherwise safely secure the tractor for his repair work in the manner required by common sense and the recognized standards of his profession.

Trucking Operations Investigations

The experts in the Trucking Operations Group at Robson Forensic have decades of experience in the trucking/transportation industry, in long haul trucking, LTL trucking, as well as non-CDL commercial transport. All are CDL licensed drivers who moved into the safety and compliance departments and became safety managers and safety directors for Motor Carriers across the United States. These experts use their countless miles of driving experience and management/oversight work to examine every facet of a trucking incident investigation.

For more information, contact the author of this article or submit an inquiry.

Featured Expert

Brooks Rugemer, Commercial Trucking Expert

Brooks Rugemer

Commercial Trucking Expert
Brooks is an experienced Transportation Manager specializing in trucking, warehousing, intermodal, and logistics related claims. After 13 years and 1.4 million miles as a CDL tractor trailer driver,… read more.


View All Articles

Sleep Deprivation and Fatigue in Commercial Trucking

By Brooks Rugemer
Expert Article

Studies suggest that fatigue and/or sleep deprivation may be a contributing factor in at least 30 to 40 percent of all heavy truck crashes. This article explores the effects of sleep deprivation and…

Falls From Trucks

By Robson Forensic
Expert Article

In this article, one of our automotive engineering experts explains some of the engineering solutions that are used to improve safety for those entering and exiting large trucks. This includes a…

Forklift Maintenance and Repair

By Stanley Jaworski
Expert Article

In this article, Mechanical Engineer, Stanley Jaworski, P.E., provides an introduction to industrial truck inspection and repair, including some of the relevant standards. Industrial Truck (Forklift)…