System Failures of Zip Line Hardware in Trees Expert Article

Trees are commonly utilized as support systems for zip lines, tree houses, and other structural applications. These arrangements can be more complex than traditional construction methods because they introduce a living organism into the system that is susceptible to disease, death, and decay. In this article, the experts discuss the use of trees as structural support members and highlights several issues relevant to their failure.

The experts at Robson Forensic are frequently retained to investigate injuries involving the design, maintenance, and operations of zip line courses. Experts involved in these matters may include recreational programming specialists, structural engineers, materials scientists, or master arborists. Contact us directly to discuss your case and determine which expert is best qualified to assist.

Zip Line Hardware in Trees

Any installation of hardware into a tree should be carefully considered in order to reduce the likelihood of future failure. Considerations should include the selection of appropriate tree species, installation location on the tree, tree size, and hardware selection and installation techniques.

Drilling any hole into a tree creates a wound that makes the tree more susceptible to infection and decay. Proper planning and craftsmanship is required to limit wounding, promote tree health, and the long term integrity of the system. Trees, as living systems, are unique amongst construction materials, because they have the ability to grow, heal, and die. Proper care, planning, and inspection will provide the best possible chances for long term structural safety.

An arborist should be consulted in the construction planning process to evaluate the viability of proposed trees and periodically after construction to perform follow-up inspections of the system.

Wood Decay

Trees have the ability to compartmentalize damage and limit the spread of decay when they are wounded. Research shows that the discoloration and decay that frequently results from the installation of dead-end and through-hardware is limited if the tree is in good health. Several factors influence the degree of discoloration and decay, and the tree’s ability to compartmentalize the wound: tree genetics and vitality; condition of wood penetrated by drill hole; time of year of installation; and the size, depth, position, and number of holes drilled all affect the tree’s wound response.

European beech showing discoloration associated with drilling a hole for through-hardware installation (29 years since installation). A more recent drill hole is evident at the bottom of the photograph: faint discoloration with the same shape as the dark drill hole discoloration. (Photo Source Journal of Arboriculture)

The image above is a European beech showing discoloration associated with drilling a hole for through-hardware installation (29 years since installation). A more recent drill hole is evident at the bottom of the photograph: faint discoloration with the same shape as the dark drill hole discoloration.


species Selection

Some trees have a more robust wound response than others; they can compartmentalize invaded tissues more effectively, thus limiting the spread of decay and damage. Trees that are good compartmentalizers are better candidates to have hardware installed verse poor compartmentalizers. Wood discoloration and decay associated with hardware installation varies with species, ability to compartmentalize can be different in individual trees depending on the condition of the tree.

Tree Size Matters

It most applications, the trunk is the most likely position for zip line anchors. Trunk diameter and wood strength should both be considered when selecting trees for anchor installation.

Methods and Installation of Hardware

When proper hardware is installed, the hole is typically drilled through the entire trunk, a bolt is inserted, and a washer and nut on the opposite end of the bolt secure it in place. For through-hardware, installation holes should be drilled no more than 1/8 inches larger than the diameter of the hardware to be installed. Holes should not be drilled closer together than the diameter of the trunk being drilled or 12 inches, whichever is less. The installation site must be inspected to assure that hardware is installed into sound wood only. Furthermore, the standards of arboriculture state that when installing through-hardware, heavy-duty or heat-treated round steel washers should be between the bark of the tree and the nut. The washer should not be countersunk into the wood.

European beech showing discoloration associated with drilling a hole for through-hardware installation (29 years since installation). A more recent drill hole is evident at the bottom of the photograph: faint discoloration with the same shape as the dark drill hole discoloration. (Photo Source Journal of Arboriculture)

The image above shows a longitudinal view of discoloration and decay extending from drill hole for hardware installation (note countersinking of washers into wood)

Wood Poles

Wood poles, whether treated or not, can decay as readily as living trees. Wood poles used as part of any zip line system should be inspected for any type of incipient decays.

Inspections

It is critical that a detailed inspection be conducted on the tree before and after any hardware is installed. If the tree and its associated parts are in poor health or structure, the hardware installation in most cases should not occur, or alternate options should be considered. The adverse physiological consequences of installing hardware by drilling holes in trees cannot be overlooked because any wound requires the tree to reallocate resources to compartmentalize the wound.

Trees with hardware installed require detailed inspections and assessments by a qualified arborist. Those inspections should involve a full ground-level assessment of the tree’s root flare, trunk, and canopy. The arborist should recognize and remove tree branches with preexisting defects that may break or fail onto zip lines or may sway into the pathway of the zip line corridor.

More so, the inspecting arborist should perform an aerial inspection of the areas of the tree where the hardware has or will be installed.

Forensic Tree Investigations

Within the context of a zip line investigation, Robson Forensic is positioned to provide a thorough and comprehensive investigation by addressing every aspect of the case, from structural engineering and materials failures, to recreational programming and tree forensics.

For more information submit an inquiry or call us at 800.813.6736.

Related Articles

View All Articles

Zip Line Injuries, Risks, and Safety

By Ian Adamson
Expert Article

In this article, Adventure & Obstacle Sports Expert, Ian Adamson, details the design, construction, operations, inspection, and maintenance of zip lines and their components, as well as common failure…

Pesticide Exposures

By Diane Trainor
Expert Article

This article provides an introduction to pesticide exposures, including background information on pesticides, how exposures occur, and information on experts who may be relevant if you have a case…

Tree Care - Expert Diagram on Hazard Tree Identification

By Robson Forensic
Expert Article

In this article, the tree experts at Robson Forensic address some of the relevant issues in tree-related litigation. He discusses physical signs that indicate a tree may be failing, industry specific…