Defense Verdict: Boy Drowned from Lack of Supervision - Supported by Expert Opinion Expert Article

In this case, Aquatics Expert, Maria Bella, was retained by defense counsel to investigate a drowning incident that occurred at a gated apartment pool.

Defense Verdict: Boy Drowned From Lack of Supervision

In this tragic incident, a two year old boy drowned at a gated pool in an apartment complex. The mother of the deceased brought suit against the apartment complex based on theories of premises liability. Plaintiff’s expert in aquatics attributed the child’s drowning to a defective gate, an overcrowded pool, and the lack of a lifeguard.

Maria Bella was retained by defense counsel to address aquatics safety aspects of the case. Ms. Bella established that any claims of a defective gate were immaterial since the purpose of the gate was to keep children out of the pool area and the plaintiff had already entered the pool area with her children. She also testified that the pool met all municipal codes relevant to the incident. Concerning claims of overcrowding, Ms. Bella was able to establish pool occupants at around 40 based on eyewitness testimony, which is approximately 25% of the pool capacity. (Ms. Bella demonstrated why the maximum capacity was 160.) Moreover, Ms. Bella provided clarification that there was no need for a lifeguard, since it was not required by municipal codes or the aquatic industry standard of care for this type of facility.

Result: The jury found that the boy drowned from a lack of supervision and the apartment complex was not negligent. More Information at Verdict Search

Featured Expert

Maria Bella, Aquatics & Drowning Expert

Maria Bella, AFOIT, CPOI

Aquatics & Drowning Expert
Maria Bella is an expert in sports and recreation and specializes in aquatic safety. She is one of only six Aquatic Facility Operator Instructor Trainers in the world and has been active in the… read more.


View All Articles

Diving Board Injury - Expert Investigation

By Maria Bella
Expert Article

A patron at a local amusement park was injured when he dove from an elevated board into a swimming pool and struck the pool bottom with his face. He sustained an abrasion to his forehead and…

Hotel Waterpark Safety Concerns

By Maria Bella
Expert Article

In this article, aquatics safety expert, Maria Bella, AFOIT, CPOI, LGI, discusses the rapid rate at which hotel waterparks are expanding and why safety may be a secondary concern as players rush to…

Indoor Swimming Pool Air Quality

By Maria Bella
Expert Article

In this article, Robson Forensic experts in Industrial Hygiene and Aquatics Safety discuss some of the issues relevant to air quality in indoor swimming areas. Indoor Air Quality in Natatoriums Cella…